Buying Box Trucks: Dealers, Rentals, or Private Sellers? (Pros & Cons)

Let’s explore the pros and cons of buying box trucks from dealerships, rental companies, and private sellers.

Audio voiceover of this guide:

Guide Contents

Dealerships, and rental companies, and private sellers—oh my! 

So, you want to buy a box truck but you can’t decide whether or not you want to: 

  1. Visit the local box truck dealership
  2. See what used rental trucks are for sale
  3. Look at what private sellers are looking to sell

In this article, we’re breaking down some of the pros and cons of buying a box truck from dealerships, rental companies, and private sellers. Let’s get started! 

What are the pros and cons of buying box trucks from dealerships?

box truck dealership

The Pros of Buying Box Trucks from Dealerships

Great Selection

One potential pro of buying box trucks from dealerships is that you may have a wider selection of trucks to choose from. Dealerships often have a range of different makes and models available, which can allow you to find the right truck for your needs. 

Financing & Maintenance Programs

Buying from a dealership may also provide you with access to financing options and other forms of support, such as warranties, maintenance, and repair services.

The Cons of Buying Box Trucks from Dealerships

Expensive Pricing
A potential downside of buying box trucks from dealerships is that they may be more expensive than other options. Box truck dealerships may offer largely new models, which can be much more costly than used boxed trucks. Dealerships also often have overhead costs such as showroom and sales staff expenses. For these reasons, the prices of their box trucks may be higher than those offered by other sellers. 

Dealing with Salespeople

Additionally, buying from a dealership may also require you to interact with a salesperson who may have their own agenda. Some consider this process time-consuming and potentially stressful.

What are the pros and cons of buying box trucks from rental companies?

buying box trucks from rental companies

The Pros of Buying Box Trucks from Rental Companies

Competitive Pricing

One potential pro of buying box trucks from rental companies is that they may be less expensive than buying from a dealership. Because rental companies typically purchase their trucks in bulk and have a special incentive to offload used vehicles, they may be able to offer them at a lower price than a dealership. 

Financing & Maintenance

Some rental sales companies can offer the best of both worlds in terms of deals, financing, and perks. Buying from a rental company may also provide you with access to financing options and other forms of support—such as maintenance and repair services.

The Cons of Buying Box Trucks from Rental Companies

Limited Selection

An occasional downside of buying box trucks from rental companies is that the selection of trucks available may be limited. Rental companies often have a smaller range of makes and models available for purchase, as they typically only sell their older or less commonly used trucks. This varies based on the rental company. 

Box Truck Condition

Box trucks rented out by rental companies were driven by a wide variety of drivers. Most people renting box trucks from these companies have little to no experience driving trucks of that size. Because of this, some box trucks for sale through rental companies have cosmetic or mechanical issues that are not easily spotted upon inspection. 

Dealing with Salespeople
Like a dealership, buying from a rental company may also require you to deal with a sales representative, which can be stressful for some.

What are the pros and cons of buying box trucks from a private seller?

buying box truck from a private seller

The Pros of Buying Box Trucks from Private Sellers

Likely the Best Prices

Out of all three options, buying a box truck from a private seller will typically fetch the lowest prices for trucks. Private sellers are not subject to the same overhead costs as dealerships or rental companies allowing them to offer their trucks at a lower price. In addition to a lack of overhead, many private sellers are highly motivated to sell, putting the negotiating power mostly with the buyer. 

The Cons of Buying Box Trucks from a Private Seller

Lack of Financing or Support

Depending on the buyer’s position, a con of buying box trucks from a private seller is a lack of the usual support and services as a dealership or rental company. Private sellers may not offer financing options or maintenance and repair services, so you may have to arrange these things on your own. Acquiring financing for box trucks purchased through private sellers may be harder to procure through banks and other lending institutions.

Mysterious Vehicle Condition

Buying a box truck from a mysterious private seller from the classified ads may also come with some uncertainty. You may not have the same level of information about the history and condition of the truck as you would from a dealership or rental company. For this reason, it is important to have any box truck inspected by a mechanic before making a purchase.

Finding Box Trucks for Sale from Dealers, Rentals, or Private Sellers

If you’re in the market for a new or used box truck for sale, you can find precisely what you’re looking and from the seller of your choice at My Little Salesman. Filter your search by region, price, make, model, style, seller, and beyond to find your ideal box truck. 

Find Your Box Truck for Sale Today

By on
About Ken Lane
Ken’s affinity for the heavy equipment industry was fostered as a curious youngster—becoming happily lost on his grandfather’s tractor sales and service lot (his favorite color is still Allis-Chalmers Orange). Since then, he’s perfected the art of turning black coffee into helpful buyer resources and marketing materials for My Little Salesman.
More in Advice & Tips